If you only shoot one target with your broadheads, get the Rinehart 18-1. Its 18 distinct shooting faces and self-healing foam spread blade damage across the whole cube, and it is rated to 500 FPS, so the same block handles broadhead tuning, field point zeroing and a full crossbow session. That combination of impact distribution, speed headroom and a 2-pound carry weight is why it tops our list of the best archery targets for broadheads.
That ranking matters more than it sounds. A broadhead is a set of razors traveling at 300-plus FPS, and a target that was never designed for them will shred from the inside out long before the arrow count gets interesting. The forum consensus we pulled while researching this is blunt: shooters on r/bowhunting keep repeating that if you want to shoot broadheads, buy layered foam or a block, and that shooting them into a bag target is a bad idea. A bag target is a practice tool for field points. It is not a broadhead target.
Over the last few weeks our team lined up ten of the highest-rated broadhead targets on the market and worked through the manufacturer specs, the owner reports and the failure modes for each one. Between them these ten targets carry more than 9400 owner reviews, which gave us enough long-term durability evidence to do more than read marketing copy. We paid particular attention to the single question that separates a good target from a good broadhead target: what happens to the foam after the blade goes through.
We also flagged the trade-offs honestly, because none of these targets wins on every axis. Two of the 3D models are genuinely hard to pull arrows from, one of the highest-rated blocks has a tiny scoring face, and the fastest crossbow-rated block on the list states field points only in its own listing. You will find those warnings below, attached to the product they apply to.
Table of Contents
Top 3 Broadhead Picks for (September 2026)
Morrell High Roller
- 6 sides with 21 bullseyes
- 450 FPS rating
- Waterproof self-healing foam
- 13 inch cube
Quick Overview: The Best Archery Targets for Broadheads in 2026
All ten targets in the table below are rated for broadhead-tipped arrows, but they are not equal. Three use self-healing solid foam, two rely on layered polyethylene, two are built around open friction layers that release arrows unusually easily, two are 3D anatomy targets, and one uses a woven synthetic mesh.
| Product | Specs | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Rinehart 18-1 Cube |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Black Hole 4-Sided |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Morrell High Roller |
|
Check Latest Price |
 BLOCK Classic |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Morrell Yellow Jacket |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Rinehart RhinoBlock |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Power-Stop High-Density |
|
Check Latest Price |
 SpyderWeb 18XL |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Delta McKenzie 3D Deer |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Delta McKenzie 3D Bear |
|
Check Latest Price |
Choosing an Archery Target for Broadheads: Solid Foam vs Layered Foam
The whole category divides on one material question, so this is the section to read before you buy anything. Foam archery targets come in two families: solid self-healing foam, where the material is one continuous mass, and layered foam, where bonded sheets are stacked to build the block. They behave completely differently once a broadhead is involved.
A broadhead blade does not push foam aside, it cuts it. In solid self-healing foam, the cut opens and the surrounding material pushes closed, so the hole largely seals itself and the block keeps its shape. In layered foam, the blade finds the adhesive lines between sheets and starts separating them, so damage spreads laterally from the entry hole and the face delaminates outward from where you are actually shooting.
There is a third construction in this list that deserves its own category: open, unglued friction layers. Arrows enter between separate sheets, friction heat grips the shaft briefly, and cooling releases it. The result is a target that stops arrows with friction rather than force, and that is genuinely the easiest kind of broadhead target to pull arrows from. It is also the most physically forgiving, because a badly aimed broadhead usually has nothing to latch onto.
Here is how the three compare on the factors that actually matter for broadheads:
Solid self-healing foam seals holes, resists delamination and tolerates high arrow counts. The trade-off is extraction force, since the same grip that stops the arrow holds it there.
Layered polyethylene localizes damage inside a single sheet, so one bad group does not ruin the whole face. The trade-off is that blades exploit the layer lines, and a slowly degrading target can crumble in chunks.
Open friction layers give the easiest arrow removal of any construction here. The trade-off is lower speed headroom, because the arrow is slowed by drag rather than stopped by mass.
For blade width, mechanical broadheads with offset or multi-blade designs are the hard case. Their cutting edges are wider than a single fixed-blade edge and they slice laterally, which accelerates delamination in layered foam. Fixed-blade broadheads with a narrow cutting profile are the easiest case, and they are what most owners in this lineup are shooting.
One more point on speed. A printed FPS rating tells you what the target was tested to stop, not what your setup produces. If you shoot a crossbow or a high-speed compound, match the rating to your fastest arrow, not your average. Three of the ten targets below are rated at or above 450 FPS, and one states no speed limit at all.
1. Rinehart 18-1 Cube Target: Best Overall for Broadheads
Rinehart 18-1 Archery Target, 18-Sided, Broadhead & Field Point Compatible
18 shooting faces
Self-healing foam
Rated to 500 FPS
Weighs 2 pounds
Pros
- 18 faces spread arrow impact and extend target life
- Broadhead capable and rated to 500 FPS
- Crossbow approved for mixed-bow households
- Only 2 pounds with an easy-carry handle
- 4.6 stars from 813 reviews with 81 percent five-star
Cons
- Requires a separately purchased stand or backstop
- 15 inch cube face is less scoring surface than 18 to 20 inch blocks
The Rinehart 18-1 is the reason this roundup comes out the way it does. It is an 18-sided cube with 18 separate shooting faces, built from Rinehart’s self-healing signature foam, rated to 500 FPS and crossbow approved. That face count is the quiet advantage: instead of hammering the same six inches of foam, you are rotating around the entire cube, so each scoring zone takes a fraction of the hits.
It also happens to be the easiest of the serious high-speed options to move. At 2 pounds with a built-in carry handle, you can walk it from the truck bed to a tree stand or a camp clearing without a dolly. Owners rate it 4.6 stars across 813 reviews, and 81 percent of those are five-star.
Two practical notes from people who own it. On forum.eastmans, one shooter argues that a plain block works just as well for field points and broadheads as a Rinehart 18-1, and that argument is not unreasonable. What you are really paying for with the 18-1 is the face count and the 500 FPS rating, not a secret foam formula. If your shooting never exceeds a 350 FPS compound, a cheaper block will serve you fine.
The honest downside is size. At 15 inches on a side, this cube has less total scoring surface than the 18 and 20 inch blocks in this list, and it does not stand up on its own. Plan on a stand or a backstop, and remember that a 15 inch face is a close-range and mid-range tool rather than a 70-yard target.
Why broadheads stay contained
Self-healing foam is the whole story here. The blade opens a wound, the foam closes it, and because you have 18 faces to rotate between, no single face accumulates the ragged, delaminated look you get on a two-sided block after a season of fixed-blade shooting. The 500 FPS rating also means a crossbow bolt or a heavy high-speed compound arrow is stopped by the same cube you use for tuning at 30 yards.
For a bowhunter, that combination is the point. You can zero with field points, then confirm the point of impact with the exact broadheads you will hunt with, on the same target, without worrying that the block is going to collapse after a dozen arrows.
Where it falls short
Two things will frustrate you. The first is the stand: this is a cube, not a self-supporting block, and the stand is a separate purchase that a lot of buyers overlook. The second is the small face, which means your scoring surface is modest for the weight and the rating.
Neither issue is a broadhead problem. If your priority is stopping blades and shooting fast arrows in one package, the 18-1 is the cleanest answer in this roundup.
2. Black Hole 4-Sided Target: Best Value Broadhead Setup
Black Hole 4-Sided Archery Target, 18″ x 16″ x 11″, 300 FPS, Uses Friction Not Force to Stop All Field Points and Broadheads, Open-Face Layered Design, Lightweight and Carry Strap for Portability
Ethafoam open-layer design
Four shooting sides
8 ounce carry weight
Stops 300 FPS arrows
Pros
- Dedicated open-face sides for broadheads and expandables
- Friction-not-force layers make removal easy
- 4 sides spread impact across the block
- 8 ounces with a built-in carry handle
- Largest review base here at 5500 reviews
Cons
- Shooting the outer edge can cut the wrap band
- Center bullseyes wear faster if all shots cluster
- Bolt speed needs the separate 16 inch model
At 8 ounces and four shooting sides, the Black Hole is the target we recommend to anyone who wants to practice with broadheads without hauling 30 pounds of foam down to the range. It ranks first in archery targets on Amazon and carries more owner reviews than anything else in this list, which means the durability picture is unusually well documented.
The design is the interesting part. The open-layer construction stops arrows with friction instead of force, and the target comes with sides designated for broadheads and expandables alongside wrapped sides for field points. In practice owners report that the broadhead sides stay forgiving, because a blade that misses the scoring area tends to slide rather than bury itself.
It stops standard diameter arrows up to 300 FPS in the 18 and 22 inch wide sizes, which covers the large majority of hunting and practice bows. If your speeds are lower, the friction approach still works because the mechanism is drag-based rather than mass-based.
What you give up is raw durability at high arrow counts. A 4.5-star average across 5500 reviews with 73 percent five-star is a strong showing, but the complaints cluster in one predictable place: the bullseyes wear out faster than the block, because that is where everyone shoots.
What makes removal easy
The friction mechanic works because the arrow enters between unglued layers and generates heat on the way in, which briefly grips the shaft, then releases as it cools. A broadhead has already done its cutting by the time it reaches that zone, so the blades are not what is holding your arrow. That is why broadhead removal on this target is consistently reported as easier than field point removal on the same block.
For most people this is the feature that matters most. The target lives in a garage or a shed, and the twenty minutes you would lose wrestling arrows out of solid foam is the twenty minutes you spend shooting.
Where it falls short
Two failure modes to plan around. First, shooting the outer edge of a face can cut the wrap band that binds the layers together, and once that band is gone the face is compromised. Second, if you put every arrow in the center, the bullseyes deteriorate long before the foam does. Rotate your groups.
Also note that crossbow capability lives in a separate 16 inch model rated to 375 FPS, not in the standard target. If you shoot a crossbow, buy the right size rather than assuming the bigger one covers it.
3. Morrell High Roller Foam Cube: Best for 450 FPS Compound Shooting
Morrell High Roller Foam Archery Target, 6 Sided Cube with 21 Bullseye, Red
6-sided cube with 21 bullseyes
450 FPS rating
13 inch cube
12 pounds
Pros
- Highest rated target here at 4.8 stars from 213 reviews
- 21 bullseyes across 6 sides spread impact
- Stops arrows up to 450 FPS from compound and crossbow
- Waterproof foam resists wear and fading
- Integrated EZ-Tote carry handle
Cons
- Smallest scoring face among the cubes at 13 inches
- 12 pounds is heavy for its size
- Smaller review base than the other foam options
The Morrell High Roller has the highest average rating of anything we evaluated, 4.8 stars from 213 reviews with 89 percent five-star, and the rating distribution is unusually clean. It is also rated to 450 FPS, so it handles high-speed compound arrows and crossbow bolts in the same cube.
The construction is high-density self-healing foam in a waterproof, fade-resistant shell, with 21 bullseyes spread across 6 sides. That is a lot of surface area for a cube this size, and owners note that the foam both stops the arrow and then releases it afterward, which is rarer than it should be among high-density blocks.
Owners also report year-round outdoor use without complaint, and the built-in EZ-Tote handle is a genuine improvement over the strap arrangements on some competing cubes. The waterproof shell matters in practice, because foam that absorbs water gets heavier and starts to slump.
The catch is scale. This is a 13 inch cube weighing 12 pounds, and those two numbers work against each other. You get the smallest scoring face in the cube category with a weight that is heavier than comparable foam blocks, so it is not the target to carry a quarter mile into the woods.
Why the rating is so high
Two things drive the 89 percent five-star share. The first is that the 450 FPS rating is honest, and the second is the combination of 21 bullseyes on 6 sides with self-healing foam, which means a bowhunter can run a full pre-season tune-up without turning one face into confetti. The 2 percent one-star share suggests very few buyers feel shortchanged.
For most tuning workflows, this is the ideal shape of target. You shoot a group, note the drift, walk around the cube, and shoot the next group on a fresh face.
Where it falls short
Thirteen inches is small for long-distance work. Past 40 or 50 yards the group grows and a 13 inch face becomes frustrating, even with a good spotting system. And with only 213 reviews, there is less multi-year durability evidence here than the Black Hole or BLOCK entries have, which matters if you want to know how the foam looks after three hunting seasons.
Twelve pounds is also a real carry weight for a target this compact, so budget for a cart if you are moving it any distance.
4. BLOCK Classic Layered Foam Target: Best for Close-Range Tuning
BLOCK Classic Layered Foam Archery Target, 18” x 18” x 13.5”, 2-Sided Shooting, Unique Open Layer Design Stops Field Points and Broadheads with Friction Not Force, Easy Arrow Removal, Top Carry Handle
Open unglued friction layers
2-sided shooting
18 inch face
8 ounces
Pros
- Friction-layer design gives easy removal with fixed blades
- 2-sided high-contrast face for fast target acquisition
- 8 ounces with a top carry handle
- One owner logged about 3000 recurve shots before pass-through
- Stopped a 350 FPS crossbow bolt broadhead-first
Cons
- Bullseyes wear faster than the block under broadheads
- Mechanical broadheads on bolts can push past the vanes quickly
- Outer edge hits can cut the layer wrap
The BLOCK Classic is an 18 by 18 by 13.5 inch block with patented open, unglued friction layers, and it is the target we would pick for tuning at 30 and 45 yards. It weighs 8 ounces, has a top carry handle, and its reversed black-and-white layout is one of the fastest to acquire visually in this whole roundup.
Owner feedback on broadhead durability is unusually concrete. One recurve shooter logged roughly 3000 shots before arrows started passing through, and another confirmed the block stopping a 350 FPS crossbow bolt with broadheads fitted after 2 to 4 inches of penetration. That is real evidence, not a spec sheet promise.
On ArcheryTalk, shooters who tune with broadheads point to the BLOCK Classic 22 inch version specifically for 70 and 80 yard work, because it is lighter to carry at distance than the bigger alternatives. That is forum-level advice we agree with: match the target size and weight to the distance you actually shoot.
It scores 4.6 stars from 971 reviews with 77 percent five-star, and the blank back face gives you a surface for chalk-mark instinct practice, which is a nice touch for sight-in work.
How friction layers handle blades
Because the layers are unglued, a broadhead has no adhesive line to follow. The blade cuts its entry hole in one sheet, the arrow drags into the next, friction grips the shaft briefly and then releases it. In practice broadhead arrows come out easier here than field point arrows, which is the opposite of what happens on most solid foam.
That is also why this target is a good first recommendation for a new archer who wants to shoot the same broadheads they will hunt with, without a wrestling match on the shooting line.
Where it falls short
The printed bullseyes degrade faster than the block itself under fixed-blade and mechanical broadhead use, and reviewers specifically report that a mechanical broadhead on a crossbow bolt can push past the vanes in a handful of shots. The 18 inch face is also small for high-power crossbow work, and hitting the outer edge can cut the wrap that binds the layers.
It is a tuning and practice target rather than a high-volume crossbow target. Shoot it at field point speeds and it will last for years.
5. Morrell Yellow Jacket Dual Threat: Best for Mixed Point Types
Morrell Yellow Jacket Dual Threat 380 FPS Foam Archery Target Block, Yellow
4 sides with 32 bullseyes
Rated to 380 FPS
Fused cellular foam
16 ounces
Pros
- Explicitly accepts field points fixed blades and mechanical broadheads
- 32 bullseyes across 4 sides stretch target life
- Stops 300+ FPS compound arrows in 6 to 7 inches
- One owner reported 10000 shots on a first unit
- Weather-resistant surface with an easy-carry handle
Cons
- Arrows can be very hard to pull without a puller tool
- Some 325 FPS field tips passed through in a minority of setups
- Broadheads tear the printed white bullseye circles
- Bulky to move despite the low listed weight
The Yellow Jacket Dual Threat is the most explicitly broadhead-friendly product in this roundup. The manufacturer states that it accommodates field points, fixed-blade broadheads and mechanical broadheads, and the 380 FPS rating covers most high-speed compound setups. It is sold in 380 and 350 FPS variants, so you can match it to your bow rather than guessing.
Fused cellular foam with offset bullseye technology gives it 32 bullseyes across 4 sides, and that impact-spreading layout is the reason for the durability reports. One owner logged 10000 shots on a first unit and was still stopping recurve arrows, and broadhead damage tends to be limited to the printed white circles rather than the foam itself.
At 16 ounces it is also light enough to move with one hand, and foam construction is not attractive to the mice that destroy straw and straw-blend targets within a season or two. The weather-resistant surface takes rain and sun without complaint.
What pulls the rating down to 4.3 stars from 828 reviews is retrieval. Multiple owners say an arrow puller is effectively required, and there is a notable 9 percent one-star share, the highest among the foam blocks here. That feedback concentrates on the seller return experience rather than the target itself, but it still shows up in the score.
Why 32 bullseyes matter
Every bullseye you spread across a target is a bullseye that absorbs fewer blade cuts. With 32 of them on 4 sides, a typical practice session barely touches any one zone, so the target keeps working long after a two-sided block has a ragged face. The offset bullseye placement also means the printed markings are less likely to be destroyed in one concentrated group.
This is the target to pick if your shooting alternates between hunting broadheads, practice broadheads and field points in the same session, because it is designed for exactly that mix.
Where it falls short
Arrow removal is the honest weak point. Broadheads grip hard enough here that several owners keep a puller tool within reach, and cold weather makes it worse because foam contracts. A minority of setups with slower bows and field tips also reported pass-through, which is what drives most of the critical reviews.
It is also bulky to move despite the 16 ounce listed weight, and it comes with a single handle. Plan ahead if you are hauling it across a yard or to a stand.
6. Rinehart RhinoBlock: Best for Deer Anatomy Practice
Rinehart RhinoBlock Target, 6-Sided, Broadhead Compatible
6 faces including 2 anatomy zones
Self-healing foam
16 x 16 x 13 inches
Handles fixed blades and expandables
Pros
- Two faces carry 3D deer anatomy zones and organ diagrams
- Self-healing foam seals arrow holes instantly
- Handles field points fixed blades and expandables
- Block shape is more stable for crossbow shooting
- 16 inch and 18 inch sizes available
Cons
- Highest one-star share of the Rinehart entries at 11 percent
- Requires a separate stand
- Listed item weight looks inconsistent for a block this size
The RhinoBlock is the only foam block here that trains shot placement as well as accuracy. Two of its six faces carry 3D deer anatomy zones, one of them with an anatomically correct organ diagram, and the other four are high-visibility dot targets for volume practice. That is a genuinely different proposition from the rest of this roundup.
The foam is the same self-healing signature series used in the Rinehart 18-1, specified to seal holes instantly and handle field points, fixed-blade broadheads and expandables. The 16 by 16 by 13 inch block shape is more stable than a cube when you are shooting a crossbow, and an 18 inch version is available if you want more face.
ArcheryTalk shooters who tune with broadheads specifically praise the RhinoBlock XL for close-range work, and the anatomy faces explain why: you can rehearse a shot placement on a deer instead of guessing at a paper ring. For pre-season bowhunting practice that is worth more than another dot face.
It is also the product the price conversation in the forums usually centers on. One r/bowhunting comment captures the sentiment exactly: Rinehart targets are objectively better, but also mad expensive. The 4.2 star average from 247 reviews, with 70 percent five-star, suggests most buyers accept the trade.
Anatomy faces versus dot faces
Dot faces teach you to repeat a shot. Anatomy faces teach you where a shot actually kills. The RhinoBlock lets you do both on one block, which is a real advantage over buying a separate 3D target, and the organ diagram face is the closest thing to a classroom aid in a foam block.
For broadhead shooters, the practical sequence is to confirm your group on a dot face, then walk to an anatomy face and rehearse the shot you intend to take in the field.
Where it falls short
Eleven percent one-star reviews is the highest one-star share among the Rinehart products here, and that wide spread points to real variability in what arrives. It also requires a separate stand, and the listed item weight of 7.2 ounces looks inconsistent for a solid foam block of this size, so do not plan on it being a one-hand carry.
It is a premium-tier purchase, and if you only need accuracy practice, the 18-1 gives you more faces for less money.
7. Power-Stop High-Density Block: Best Layered Core for Blade Damage
Power-Stop Archery Targets – 19″ High-Density Block Target – 350fps Foam Target Block for Broadheads and Field Tips…
Layered polyethylene core
350 FPS rating
6-sided shooting
19 inch block
Pros
- Layered core localizes blade damage to a single sheet
- Stopped a 465 grain 360 FPS crossbow bolt with broadheads
- 6-sided shooting with a battleship game face
- Made in the USA by a dedicated foam fabricator
- Weather resistant and reusable
Cons
- Removal is the dominant complaint and needs real force
- Some owners report foam breaking out in chunks after about 50 arrows per side
- Field tips grip harder than broadheads on this block
- Smaller review base at 181 reviews
Power-Stop is the layered-polyethylene case study in this roundup, and it makes the strongest argument for that construction. Specially engineered high-density layered foam gives it a durability profile that some owners describe as the longest-lasting block they have owned, holding up after thousands of arrows.
The mechanism is straightforward: each sheet is dense enough to stop an arrow on its own, so a blade cut stays inside the layer it was made in instead of tracing an adhesive line outward. Owners also report that broadheads pull out more easily than field tips, which is the reverse of most solid foam and a genuinely useful quirk.
Broadhead stopping is verified at real crossbow speeds. One documented test stopped a 465-grain bolt from a 285 pound pull crossbow at 360 FPS with broadheads fitted, roughly halfway through the block. The target is rated to 350 FPS and shoots on 6 sides, one of which is a battleship game face for practice variety.
It is made in the USA by American Excelsior Company, a dedicated foam fabricator, and it comes with a heavy handle plus a weather-resistant build for year-round outdoor placement. A 19 inch size is available for more face area.
One practical note for crossbow shooters. The block is rated for arrows and bolts up to 350 FPS, so pair it with a crossbow in that range rather than assuming the label covers a faster setup, and keep a puller tool in your quiver bag from the first session.
When layered foam beats solid foam
Layered foam wins in one specific scenario: when your broadhead groups are tight and you keep shooting the same face. A solid block in that situation slowly sags around a concentrated wound, while a layered block sheds the damaged sheet’s worth of material and keeps its shape across the rest of the face.
It also explains the retrieval split. Because the arrow stops inside one dense sheet rather than being gripped by a continuous mass, you sometimes need real force, but the foam does not hold the blade.
Where it falls short
Retrieval is the dominant complaint, and it is severe enough that multiple owners describe standing on the block to free an arrow, particularly with field tips. There is also a durability counterpoint: some owners report foam beginning to break out in chunks after roughly 50 arrows per side, which is the layered construction failing in the opposite direction.
With 181 reviews and a 4.4 star average, the evidence base is thinner than most of this list. Buy an arrow puller before you buy this target.
8. SpyderWeb 18XL: Best for Extreme Crossbow Bolt Speed
SpyderWeb 18XL No Speed Limit Crossbow Target 500+ FPS
Tested beyond 700 FPS
Spylar woven mesh
18 x 18 x 14 inches
34 pounds
Pros
- Only target here with an explicit no speed limit claim
- Bolts penetrate just 8 to 10 inches with little damage
- Owners pull bolts out with two fingers
- More than 200 aiming points spread impact
- Weather-resistant shell and steel handle for outdoor use
Cons
- Heaviest option here at 34 pounds
- Highest priced crossbow-rated block
- Listing highlight states field points only
- Requires a stand for shooting
Nothing else in this roundup handles raw speed like the SpyderWeb 18XL. It is tested to stop speeds beyond 700 FPS and uses Spylar woven mesh rather than solid foam, so it will stop crossbow bolts, compound arrows and even airbows that would pass through a conventional block.
The mesh is also why owners love it. Bolts penetrate only 8 to 10 inches and come out with almost no force, to the point that one reviewer reports a small child pulling a 400 FPS crossbow bolt out of it. More than 200 strategically placed aiming points spread impact across the face, which is what allows that kind of penetration without destroying the target.
It scores 4.7 stars from 280 reviews with 88 percent five-star, and owners repeatedly describe it as expensive but worth it, which tells you the value case is being made for them rather than by them. Several bought it after cycling through five cheaper targets that failed to stop arrows or trapped bolts. Verified results include 410 FPS and 500-plus FPS compound setups, and it doubles as a bow unload aid at the end of a hunt.
Built in St. Joseph, Michigan, with a weather-resistant outer shell and a heavy-duty steel handle, it is designed to live outside year round. A 30-day guarantee is included.
It is also the only product here sold specifically as a crossbow target rather than a general foam block, which is why the speed claim is stated so plainly. Buyers arrive with a clear use case in mind rather than hoping the target copes with their bow.
Read the field points note carefully
The product listing highlight for this target specifies field points only, which means broadhead compatibility is less explicitly stated here than on the foam blocks. That matters for a roundup about broadheads, and we would not recommend it as a first broadhead target without verifying with the manufacturer first.
The mesh construction is a plausible risk with a razor blade. A broadhead that catches a woven strand can tear it, and woven materials do not self-heal the way self-healing foam does.
Where it falls short
At 34 pounds it is deliberately difficult to reposition, which owners treat as a feature because it will not slide around in wind. It is also the highest priced crossbow-rated block here, and it needs a stand for shooting.
For a high-speed crossbow shooter who mainly shoots bolts, this is the target built for that job. For a bowhunter dialing in broadheads, the Rinehart 18-1 is the safer purchase.
9. Delta McKenzie Challenger 3D Deer: Best for 3D Shot Placement
Riverbottom Challenger 3D Archery Target
Life-size 3D deer foam target
Realistic organ zones
16 pounds
Includes ground stakes
Pros
- Realistic 3D deer profile with generous shot placement zones
- One owner put 300 arrows through it in a weekend and it stayed solid
- Owners rate it more durable than cheaper foam 3D alternatives
- Mixing field points and practice broadheads works well
- Includes its own working ground stakes
Cons
- Arrows and bolts are near impossible to extract
- Broadheads are occasionally lost inside the foam
- Plastic legs will not hold it upright without a stand or blocking
- Plastic legs can shatter if struck
- Lowest average rating here at 4.1 stars
The Challenger is a life-size 3D deer with anatomically placed shot placement zones, and buyers who have used far costlier premium 3D targets describe it as comparable for training. One owner put 300 arrows through it over a weekend, mixing practice broadheads and field points, and reported no degradation at the end of it.
It is also the most portable 3D on this list at 16 pounds, and it includes its own working ground stakes so you can set it in a field without building a stand. A satisfaction guarantee is included, and the large size is roughly comparable to a doe or yearling deer.
For broadhead shooters the appeal is simple: this is the one place on the list where you can rehearse a realistic deer rather than a foam face. Practicing on a deer at 40 yards teaches you to hold under and pick a spot, which no dot face can replicate.
Mixing point types works, and owners use it deliberately: field points for volume groups during the week, practice broadheads for the last few arrows to confirm the point of impact matches what the hunting arrows will do.
It rates 4.1 stars from 249 reviews, the lowest average here, and 12 percent of those reviews are one-star, by far the highest share in the roundup. Read the complaints before you buy, because they are not cosmetic.
Why 3D targets get the lowest scores
A 3D target is a body, not a block. There are no flat layers to separate and no friction surface to release an arrow, so broadheads bury themselves inside the foam. Multiple reviewers describe extraction as near impossible, and some broadheads are simply lost inside the animal.
The realistic use case is limited broadhead volume on a 3D target, with the bulk of your practice on a foam block. Owners who do that report excellent results.
Where it falls short
The flexible plastic legs will not hold the target upright reliably on their own, and they can shatter if an arrow strikes them. Most owners block between the legs or use a stand. One review also reports foam rails arriving torn, requiring adhesive before the head would attach.
It is a practice prop, not a permanent installation. Mount it properly, shoot it sparingly with blades, and it rewards you with the most realistic practice available.
10. Delta McKenzie Life-Size Bear 3D: Best 3D With a Replaceable Core
Delta McKenzie Aim Rite Bear 3D Archery Target – Self-Healing Foam, Lifelike Hunting Practice Target for Backyard, Field Points & Broadheads
Life-size black bear design
Dura-Flex foam with replaceable core
350 FPS rating
25 pounds
Pros
- Life-size realistic black bear for shot placement practice
- Handles field points plus fixed-blade and expandable broadheads
- Replaceable core lets you renew the target instead of discarding it
- Owners report year-round outdoor use including a full winter
- Integrated handle despite the 25 pound listed weight
Cons
- Some owners say the foam is not truly self-healing
- Dense sticky foam makes crossbow arrow removal very difficult
- A real bear tore one of these out of the ground
- Best on a stump or plank rather than bare ground
This bear is built differently from every other 3D in this roundup because of the replaceable core. Dura-Flex solid foam is used with a core you can swap out, so when the target is chewed up you renew the insert rather than buying a new animal. That single feature addresses the forum complaint that broadheads destroy any target over time.
It is rated for compound bows and crossbows up to 350 FPS and is explicitly compatible with field points, fixed-blade broadheads and expandable broadheads, which is the most complete broadhead compatibility statement on any 3D target we looked at. It comes in 26 inch and 28 inch heights with an integrated handle.
Owners report year-round outdoor use without problems, including one who kept it outside through a full winter. The realistic black bear silhouette is life-size, and 25 pounds is manageable with the handle for a target of this scale.
What a replaceable core changes
On a foam block, damage is distributed and the target just wears down. On a 3D animal, damage concentrates where the chest and shoulder cavities are, and once those areas are chewed out the target stops teaching you anything. A replaceable core means you can restore that area instead of replacing the animal.
That is the same logic behind replacement-core foam blocks, and it is the longevity feature bowhunters on r/bowhunting single out most often as the reason their targets last.
Where it falls short
The camp split is clear. Casual home shooters and bowhunters like it, while club and high-volume shooters rate it lower: the foam is sticky and dense enough that even 350 FPS crossbow arrows require extraordinary strength and tools to remove, and some owners say the foam is not truly self-healing as holes accumulate.
Mount it on a wooden stump or plank rather than the ground, and note that one reviewer documents an actual bear tearing the target out of the ground and destroying it. That is an unusual field report, but in bear country it is a real consideration.
How We Evaluated 10 Broadhead Targets
We did not put tens of thousands of arrows through these targets ourselves, so we want to be clear about where our evidence comes from. These ten products carry more than 9400 owner reviews between them. We read those reviews in full, cross-checked each against the manufacturer specification data, and prioritized reports that mention arrow count, broadhead type and bow speed rather than general satisfaction.
For every product we scored four things: whether the manufacturer explicitly rates the target for broadheads, what the foam construction does when a blade opens a hole, the stated or verified speed rating, and what owners report about arrow removal. Weight, dimensions, warranty and shooting surface count came from the specification data.
Where an owner reported a specific number, such as 10000 shots on one Yellow Jacket or 300 arrows through a 3D deer over a weekend, we treated it as a single data point rather than a guarantee. Long-term claims like an 11 percent one-star share on one product are reported as observed, not predicted.
Broadhead Target Buying Guide: 7 Things That Decide It
Foam type comes first, and we have covered it above: solid self-healing foam survives blades best overall, layered polyethylene contains damage best, and open friction layers give the easiest removal. If you shoot a lot of broadheads, self-healing foam is the safer default.
Broadhead type decides the rest. Fixed-blade broadheads with a narrow cutting profile are the least demanding case, and every target on this list handles them. Mechanical broadheads with offset or multi-blade designs cut wider and will destroy layered foam faster, so pair them with self-healing foam. The Morrell Yellow Jacket is the one product here that names mechanical broadheads explicitly.
Speed rating should match your fastest arrow, not your average. Targets in this roundup run from 300 FPS up to a no-speed-limit claim beyond 700 FPS. A 350 FPS compound does not need a 500 FPS block, and a high-speed crossbow absolutely does.
Shooting sides determine target life more than almost anything else. The 18-1 rotates across 18 faces, the Yellow Jacket spreads 32 bullseyes over 4 sides, and the SpyderWeb places more than 200 aiming points. More surface area means each blade cut lands somewhere fresh.
Arrow removal is the most common complaint across this entire category, and it gets worse in cold weather as foam contracts. If you shoot through November or January, buy an arrow puller before you buy a high-density block. The open friction designs need it far less, which is a genuine advantage in winter.
Size and weight should match your distance. Forum advice from ArcheryTalk is practical: a smaller 22 inch block is easier to carry to 70 and 80 yards than a larger cube, while a bigger face is better up close. Most of the targets here need a separate stand, so count that in your total setup.
Finally, think about point of impact. Shooters on r/Archery note a real discrepancy between where field points and broadheads hit, which is exactly the reason to practice with the arrows you will hunt with. Reserve your 3D targets for that purpose and use field points for volume work on your block.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you shoot a broadhead into a foam target?
Yes, but only a foam target built for it. Bag and woven-fabric targets are not designed for blades, and shooters on r/bowhunting consistently call shooting broadheads into a bag target a bad idea. Foam blocks rated for broadheads stop a 300-plus FPS arrow by closing the wound around the blade. Solid self-healing foam handles repeated broadhead shots best.
What type of foam is best for archery targets?
Solid self-healing foam is the best all-around choice for broadheads because the material closes the wound after each shot instead of separating along layer lines. Layered polyethylene localizes damage inside a single sheet, which helps when your groups are tight. Open, unglued friction layers give the easiest arrow removal of the three. Offset and mechanical broadheads wear layered foam fastest.
What is the best self-healing archery target?
The Rinehart 18-1 is the best self-healing archery target for broadheads. Its 18 shooting faces rotate impact around the whole cube, the self-healing signature foam seals arrow holes, and it is rated to 500 FPS and crossbow approved. At 2 pounds it is also far easier to move than the heavier solid blocks. It rates 4.6 stars from 813 owner reviews.
What is the best archery target for mechanical broadheads?
The Morrell Yellow Jacket Dual Threat is the clearest choice, because its manufacturer specification explicitly names mechanical broadheads alongside fixed blades and field points. It is rated to 380 FPS in a compound and crossbow configuration, with 32 bullseyes across 4 sides. The tradeoff is that arrows are hard to pull from it, so keep an arrow puller nearby.
Is it okay to shoot broadheads into a target?
It is okay with a foam block or cube rated for broadheads, which is what this entire roundup covers. Avoid bag targets and any woven or fabric face, because a blade cuts straight through the material. The one thing to check before you shoot is the speed rating: match it to your fastest arrow rather than your average, and confirm the listing names broadheads rather than field points only.
How long does an archery target last with broadheads?
It depends almost entirely on foam type and how much of the face you reuse. Owners report about 3000 shots on a BLOCK Classic with a recurve and 10000 shots on a Morrell Yellow Jacket, while some users report layered foam breaking out in chunks after roughly 50 arrows per side. Rotating across every face and using field points for volume work extends life more than any brand.
Final Verdict
For the best archery targets for broadheads, the Rinehart 18-1 wins on the combination that actually matters: 18 shooting faces, self-healing foam, a 500 FPS rating and a 2-pound carry weight. The Black Hole is the value pick at 8 ounces with dedicated broadhead faces, and the Morrell High Roller is the highest rated cube here for high-speed compound shooting.
Pick your foam type before your brand, match the speed rating to your fastest arrow, and buy an arrow puller. Then go shoot the arrows you will actually hunt with.